If you’re running retail or online arbitrage, the buying and flipping of products might feel simple — hunt a deal, list it on Amazon, make a sale. But when it comes to Amazon Arbitrage accounting, most sellers quickly discover it’s a completely different game. Amazon’s payout system is messy, margins are razor-thin, and tax season can feel like a nightmare without the right systems in place.

This guide breaks down how to set up accounting for Amazon arbitrage sellers, why accurate bookkeeping separates winners from hobbyists, and which tools and workflows make it sustainable long-term.

So how do you actually do accounting for arbitrage? You don’t need to become a CPA — you just need the right stack of tools.

This is your financial control center. It:

• Tracks income and expenses
• Produces Profit & Loss statements
• Syncs with your bank and credit cards for reconciliation
• Helps with invoicing, bill pay, and basic inventory tracking

QuickBooks tends to be best for U.S. arbitrage sellers thanks to tax integrations.

Amazon payouts are notoriously confusing. Sync tools like Link My Books break them into sales, fees, returns, and reimbursements — so you see the real numbers instead of just a lump deposit.

Without this step, arbitrage sellers are flying blind.

Sellerboard is an all-in-one profit analytics and expense tracking tool built specifically for Amazon sellers. It goes beyond surface-level revenue reporting by breaking down real profits per SKU after Amazon fees, shipping, PPC, and refunds.

Here’s where most arbitrage sellers overpay: they fail to track legitimate deductions. With margins already thin, every dollar matters. Common seller tax deductions include:

• Mileage to retail stores for RA sourcing
• Shipping supplies and prep center fees
• Home office expenses
• Amazon PPC spend
• Inventory write-offs for damaged or unsellable items

Done right, Amazon Arbitrage accounting can save you thousands at tax time.

If you want to move beyond flipping clearance deals, you’ll need:

• Clean P&Ls to secure wholesale accounts
• Balance sheets to get bank funding
• Tax-ready books to survive IRS scrutiny

Your accounting isn’t just compliance — it’s leverage. The sellers who track every dollar are the ones who win wholesale accounts, build brands, and actually scale.

Retail and online arbitrage can generate fast sales — but without disciplined accounting, it’s almost impossible to know if you’re actually profitable. Clean books protect your margins, lower your taxes, and give you the leverage to grow into wholesale, private label, or beyond.

In short: you can hustle your way into sales, but only accounting gets you into profits.

Let’s be real: Amazon arbitrage is brutal on margins. One missed deduction, one sloppy set of books, and you’re not just losing money—you’re sabotaging your own growth. The truth is, you can hustle your way into sales, but you can’t hustle your way into profits without clean accounting.

That’s where we come in. At Tall Oak Advisors, we specialize in bookkeeping and tax services for Amazon sellers who are serious about treating their business like a business. We’ll help you track every dollar, protect your margins, and keep the IRS off your back—so you can focus on sourcing, selling, and scaling.

Take two minutes to fill out our short survey to see if we are a good fit for you. You’ll walk away knowing exactly where your finances stand—and how we can turn chaos into clarity.

Affiliate Disclaimer

Some of the links in this article are affiliate links, which means we may earn a small commission if you click through and make a purchase. This comes at no additional cost to you. We only recommend products and services we genuinely believe could benefit Amazon sellers and enhance their business efficiency. Thank you for supporting us and helping keep our content free.